Make My Fish Menu (Update 2025)
Make My Fish, located in Harlem, offers a variety of fish and chips, desserts, and seafood dishes. The customer reviews speak highly of their crispy and flavorful catfish, perfectly seasoned whiting fish fillet, and delicious shrimp options. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it a beloved spot in the area. Customers commend the staff for their friendly service and the lively atmosphere. While they only accept cash, an ATM is available on-site for convenience. The menu also includes chicken wings and combo bundles, catering to various preferences. Overall, Make My Fish is a must-visit for fresh and mouthwatering seafood dishes in Harlem.
Bundles
Shrimp and Fish Combo Bundle
Includes fries. Served with your choice of coca-cola product.
Shrimp and Chips
Served with your choice of coca-cola product.
All Shrimp Bundle
Served with your choice of coca-cola product.
Chicken and Chips
All Chicken
4 pieces.
Chicken Dinner
Four pieces. Includes two sides.
Land and Sea Combo
Three wings, seven jumbo shrimps, and fries.
Chicken Wings
Whiting Fish Fillet
Fish and Chips
Four pieces.
Fish Sandwich
four pieces.
All Fish
Six pieces.
Fish and Grits
Fish and Shrimp Combo
Includes fries.
Fish Dinner
Six pieces. Includes two sides.
Fish and Shrimp Dinner
Catfish Dinner
Three pieces. Includes two sides.
Catfish Sandwich
Three pieces.
Catfish and Chips
Three pieces.
All Catfish
Four pieces.
Catfish and Grits
Three pieces.
Catfish and Shrimp Combo
Includes fries.
Triple Play
Two catfish, four whiting, seven jumbo shrimps, and fries.
Catfish and Shrimp Dinner
Catfish Fillet
Shrimp Jumbo
Shrimp and Fish Combo
Includes fries.
All Shrimp
Shrimp and Grits
Prime Time Shrimp
Shrimp Dinner
Includes two sides.